How Much Data Are You Really Giving Away Online?
I have conversations with friends constantly about whether or not they should be taking certain actions online. If you knew just how much of your digital behavior is being collected, analyzed, traded, and used to influence your decisions… you would never click “Accept All Cookies” the same way again.
Most people move through the internet like it’s a grocery store—grab a few things, scroll a little, check out, go home. But behind the scenes, you’re walking through a mall with 100+ security cameras, 30+ customer-tracking beacons, a clipboard brigade, facial recognition, purchase history tracking, and a team of analysts evaluating your every move.
I’m not exaggerating.
Let’s break down what’s really happening every time you log in, click yes, or open an app, and why small businesses need to understand the data game to protect themselves AND build trust with their customers.
The Great Data Giveaway & What It Means For Your Personal Privacy and Your Business
1. The Reality Check: What Happens When You Click “Accept All Cookies”
When you click that big happy button, you might think you're allowing the site to remember your login and show you cute content. Well, here’s what you’re actually permitting:
First-Party Cookies (Less scary)
Stored by the website you’re using. They help with:
Keeping you logged in
Remembering what’s in your cart
Saving language preferences
These are normal and helpful.
Third-Party Cookies (The Wild West)
These come from other companies — ad networks, data brokers, retargeting platforms — piggybacking on the site you're visiting.
They can track:
Your browsing behavior on other websites
Your purchase intentions
Your scroll and click patterns
Your location
Device fingerprinting
What time of day you’re active
How long you viewed something
Your behavior across multiple devices
This is how you look at one pair of shoes and suddenly the entire internet thinks you need new footwear.
Behavioral profiles
Data brokers then combine this data with:
Public records
Loyalty programs
Credit bureau data
Purchase history
Social media behavior
Location patterns
Household income estimates
Political affiliation predictions
And yes, they sell these profiles to advertisers, brands, and sometimes… whoever pays.
You're not just data. You’re a profile cluster, a “lookalike audience,” or a “consumer persona 81B: Faith-motivated homemaker, mid-income, DIY-interested, Instagram-active, primed for lifestyle purchases.”
Let that sink in.
2. What Happens When You Log In With Google, Apple, or Facebook
I know. It’s easy. One click! Boom. You're in. I do it, too.
But that convenience has a cost.
Google / Facebook / Apple Login = Granting Permissions
Depending on the permissions you allow, these companies can access:
Your name
Your email
Your birthday
Your contacts
Your profile photo
Your activity logs
Your device data
Sometimes your calendar & location (depending on the app)
And the app you logged into can share BACK data with Google or Meta.
This creates a 360-degree identity map:
what sites you log into
how often you use them
what you buy
what you search
what platforms you prefer
Yes, this helps marketers target ads. But it also means your identity is constantly being analyzed for predictive behavior.
3. Social Media Apps Are Data Vacuums
Instagram, TikTok, Snapchat, Facebook, LinkedIn, and even Pinterest collect far more data than what you tap, scroll, or save.
Across these platforms, your data profile can include:
what you watch
what you scroll past
what you linger on
your device type
your in-app behavior
your ad interactions
your location
your social graph (who you know + how often you interact)
your content preferences
your browsing behavior (on and off the app)
your purchase intent signals
AND your face geometry in some cases (yes… that’s a thing)
Facebook? Tracks everything from clicks to your political leanings.
LinkedIn? Tracks your professional interests, work history, reading habits, messaging patterns, and what content keeps you engaged.
Pinterest? Tracks your boards, search habits, what you pin vs. just glance at, your browser history (when the tag is installed), and predicts life events based on behavioral data.
These platforms don’t just know what you like. They know what you might like next. That’s why you see ads that feel eerily specific. And no, your phone isn’t “listening” to you. It’s just reading 1,000 digital breadcrumbs you didn’t realize you dropped.
4. The Pixels That Follow You Literally Everywhere
Pixels are tiny snippets of code brands install on their websites to follow your behavior across the internet. Here are some examples:
Facebook Pixel
LinkedIn Insight Tag
Pinterest Tag
TikTok Pixel
Google Ads Tag
And here’s what they track:
What pages you visit
What buttons you click
If you stay long enough to watch a video
What you add to cart
Whether you completed checkout
Whether you abandoned checkout
Whether you returned later
ALL of this gets tied to your profile. So if you looked at one coaching package? One sofa? One event ticket? Every platform now assumes this is your new personality.
5. Tools That Watch Your Screen (Yes, Like a Recording)
Did you know there are tools out there that can literally record every move you make on a given website? Here are just a few:
FullStory
Hotjar
Microsoft Clarity
And here’s what they can record:
your mouse movements
your scrolling behavior
your clicks
your rage clicks
your highlights
your navigational confusion
Some tools can even capture:
the text you typed before submitting a form
your screens as if it were a video replay
This is allowed if sensitive fields are masked and visitors are informed in the privacy policy.
But let’s be honest… no one reads those.
6. What This Means for YOU
Simply put, you need to know what tools you're using and what data you're collecting. If YOU don’t understand your own tech stack, you can’t reassure your audience. Your customers care about privacy more than ever. They want ethics in marketing. This is a competitive advantage!
Transparency = trust = revenue. Simplifying your tracking makes it easier to measure what matters. And for goodness sake, don’t install every tracking tool. Install the right ones. You don’t need FullStory AND Hotjar AND Clarity AND session replays AND heatmaps AND pixels AND scripts.
Choose intentionally.
7. How to Protect Yourself and Your Business
I know this is a lot to take in, so where do we go from here? Here are some practical, doable steps:
On a personal level:
Turn off ad personalization in Google. (Click your profile image > Manage Your Google Account > Data & Privacy > My Ad Centre > toggle OFF)
Disable third-party cookies. (Go to your browser's settings, navigate to the privacy or cookies section, and find the option to block them. The specific steps vary by browser, but you will generally find an option to block all third-party cookies or to manage exceptions for certain sites.)
Use app-specific passwords
Review “Apps with Access to Your Data” monthly. (Go to your Google Account's "Security" or "Third-party apps with account access" settings to see a list of connected apps and manage their permissions.)
Avoid “Sign in with Google” unless necessary
Don’t blindly accept cookies
Use privacy-minded browsers (Safari, Brave)
Clear tracking data monthly
On a business level:
Use only essential tracking
Clearly tell users what you track & why
Turn on form-field masking if using a tool like FullStory or Clarity
Avoid predatory retargeting
Give your audience an honest way to opt out
Track the metrics that actually matter (from your values and goals)
The most ethical, powerful approach is to track less and understand more. Track intentionally, not invasively. Build trust, not dependency.
Here’s the point.
Even if you try to lock down every piece of data about yourself online, the internet will track you. The question is: Are you participating blindly or intentionally?
On a personal level, your privacy decisions shape your digital identity. And for your business, the way you decide to track your website visitors and target audience shapes your brand integrity.
Understanding data isn’t just a tech skill. It’s way bigger than that. It’s a stewardship move. When you protect your audience’s privacy, you protect their trust. And trust is the most powerful marketing strategy you own.
Overwhelmed by marketing?
I offer ongoing marketing (and design) support through monthly retainers. Let me take it off your plate.
